Uncategorized
September 15, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
There are two names that have probably never been juxtaposed before. One is a judge on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals; the other Government and Media Counsel for the Maine Judicial Branch. What do they have in common? They are both retiring! Mary Ann Lynch After serving in this position for nine years, as […]
Read more »
September 7, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
Recently, I blogged on a Law Court decision reflecting the predicament that arises with ordinances with appellate, not de novo, ZBA review of CEO decisions. See Appletree, or CEO, J.D.? I’m now updating the chapter on civil appeals in A Practical Guide to Superior Court Practice in Maine (MCLE 2015), a process that involves reviewing […]
September 1, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
In our last entry, we took a look backwards at decisions issued by the Law Court in August. Now let’s look forward, at arguments scheduled for September 12-14. These arguments will be held in Augusta, as the SJC continues to ride the circuit. Of the ten sessions schedule from September 2017 through July 2018, five […]
August 30, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
Now that we are approaching the end of summer and the beginning of a new term for the Law Court, let’s peruse some recent rulings. While you may have been frolicking in the ocean’s surf or skimming your jet ski across a lake this month, our SJC justices were cranking out decisions. UM Insurance – […]
August 23, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
The Law Court issued a ruling in a Rule 80B appeal that once again underscores how, in the absence of the Legislature stepping in to tidy up in this area, applicants for municipal approvals will continue to act at their peril without knowledgeable counsel guiding their development efforts, and even then, they could be caught […]
August 16, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
What’s the greatest joy for a federal district court judge? One happy day might be if he’s flipped by the Court of Appeals, certiorari is granted, and the Supreme Court flips again, saying the trial court was right all along. But recently something happened even rarer, that might be even more satisfying to the Judge […]
August 14, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
Long ago, I had to decide between getting a doctorate in history at Princeton or going to law school at Northwestern. I did not want to risk living in penury and picked the latter. On August 2, the First Circuit issued a decision involving the interface between these two worlds, history and law – or, […]
August 8, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
My last blog entry got me thinking about the general question of justice delayed due to judicial action or inaction. First, I’d like to send a shout out to the Law Court for its concern about delay in Gilbert, discussed in the previous blog, and its overall promptness in practice. Generally speaking, and compared to […]
August 2, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
The Law Court recently issued two decisions of note regarding the bailiwick of Maine’s only elected judges, the Probate Court. 1. Bleak (Tiny) House? First, Estate of John W. Gilbert, 2017 ME 175. This case involved the appointment of a referee by the Probate Court (Longley, J.). The wife of a decedent and one of […]
July 24, 2017 / March 4, 2026 by Nolan Reichl
Congratulations to our Katy Rand for her victory in Carnicella v. Mercy Hospital, 2017 ME 161. This was a dispute as to whether the defendant employer discriminated against an employee under the Maine Human Rights Act, 5 M.R.S. ss. 4551-4631. The important part of this decision for precedential purposes is at the end, where the […]
